|[Frontiers in Bioscience 1, e65-71, August 1,1996]|
METHODS FOR ENHANCEMENT OF SPERM FUNCTION
Brijinder S. Minhas1 and Barry A. Ripps2
1 Assisted Reprodutive Technology, The Center for Human Reproduction,
750 North Orleans, Chicago, IL 60610
2 Division of Reproductive
Endocrinology, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University
of Florida College of Medicine, Pensacola, FL 32503
2 Division of Reproductive Endocrinology, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Florida College of Medicine, Pensacola, FL 32503
Prior to acquiring fertilization ability the sperm undergoes complex morphological and biochemical changes(4). This process of capacitation allows hyperactivated motion, zona pellucida binding, acrosome reaction and penetration. Once within the oocyte, decondensation is necessary for male pronuclear formation; thus completing the most essential goal of spermatozoa: delivery of genetic material to the oocyte.
Natural reproduction offers other obstacles requiring adequate sperm function. After vaginal deposition, a fraction of the total sperm enters the cervical mucus, potentially extending viability to four days. The fertilizing spermatozoa must traverse the female reproductive tract to reach the distal fallopian tube, the usual site of fertilization. In the absence of patent fallopian tubes or surgically correctable obstruction, these couples are constrained to in vitro fertilization for reproduction. In this environment, gamete interaction becomes dependent upon oocyte quality, sperm count, motility, morphology and ability to capacitate followed by acrosome loss(4, 5).
Fertilization hampered by oligozoospermia can be effectively overcome in vitro by employing contemporary sperm separation techniques followed by micro-insemination or intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Impaired sperm function, however, may be improved by the use of several adjuvants discussed in the following sections.
Several studies have confirmed that follicular fluid enhances sperm motility, capacitation, acrosome reaction, penetration of the zona free hamster oocytes, and fertilization rates(6-9). Mbizvo et al. showed that follicular fluid treated sperm exhibited a threefold increase in hyperactivation when compared to non-treated human sperm(10). In the same investigation they noted that the portion of the follicular fluid extracted of steroids had no stimulatory effect on sperm hyperactivation. The steroid-rich fraction of the follicular fluid stimulated hyperactivation to the same degree as whole follicular fluid(10). Meizel's group demonstrated that a G-75 sephedex fraction of human follicular fluid (HFF) was capable of inducing a physiological acrosome reaction in human spermatozoa(11). Further characterization of this G-75 fraction with organic solvent extraction followed by reverse phase HPLC identified two peaks containing acrosome reaction inducing ability. The HPLC peak with highest acrosome reaction inducing ability was identified by gas chromatography electron ionization mass spectrometry and proton NMR spectroscopy to be progesterone. The second peak was identified as 17-hydroxyprogesterone (12).
Follicular fluid is pharmacologically complex and contains a number of constituents capable of affecting sperm performance. Human follicular fluid is known to contain glycosoaminoglycans, platelet activating factor, serum albumin, and xanthine derivatives which act as phosphodiesterase inhibitors to elevate intracellular cAMP. Thus, it is becoming increasingly evident that follicular fluid is a potent stimulator of sperm performance in vitro and, in fact, may be playing an important role in vivo in modulating sperm function as the spermatozoa encounter increasing concentrations of follicular fluid in proximity of the cumulus oophorus.
Progesterone and 17-hydroxyprogesterone have been shown to cause an immediate increase in free cytosolic Ca2+ in both capacitated and non-capacitated human sperm with the effect being triggered within a few seconds of hormone treatment(13, 14). Similarly, progesterone conjugated to larger proteins was equally effective yet incapable of rapid penetration of the sperm plasma membrane. Selective expression of a progesterone receptor on human spermatozoa has been recently suggested by fluorescence microscopy and flow cytometry(15). Kinetic analysis revealed most spermatozoa that bind progesterone complete the acrosome reaction and that samples with impaired progesterone binding also fail respond with Ca2+ influx. These studies represent the first evidence of a relationship between a novel, nongenomic progesterone receptor on the surface of sperm and sperm function.
Support for a therapeutic application of progesterone was found with our demonstration of significantly improved fertilization rates of rabbit oocytes (57% versus 16%, p<0.001) when sperm were treated with progesterone for 15 minutes prior to subzonal insertion. Furthermore, this 15-minute treatment was shown to increase both the synthesis and release of PAF from rabbit spermatozoa(16). A similar mechanism seems to be operative in human spermatozoa supporting an intermediary role for PAF in the progesterone stimulation of sperm function(17). We propose that spermatozoa coming in contact with progesterone in the female reproductive tract are stimulated to synthesize and secrete PAF. Secreted PAF then stimulates sperm function in an autocrine fashion, via a cascade of secondary mediators generated by phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate breakdown and Ca2+ mobilization.
Platelet activating factor (PAF) (1-0-alkyl-2-acetyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine) belongs to a family of acetylated glycerophospholipids with a diverse spectrum of biological activities in a variety of cells types. Furthermore, many cell types possess the ability to synthesize PAF upon stimulation(18).
PAF has been identified as an endogenous component of spermatozoa from several species including human (19-22). Lipids from spermatozoa are extracted by the method of Bligh and Dyer(23). Separation and purification is achieved by thin layer chromatography. Biological PAF activity is confirmed by aggregation of washed rabbit platelets and quantification is achieved by organic phosphate analysis(19, 24).
Furthermore, spermatozoa possess the enzymatic complement to synthesize and metabolize PAF. Acetyltransferase, the enzyme necessary for PAF formation from lyso-PAF, and acetylhydrolase, the enzyme responsible for removing the acetate group from the PAF molecule and converting it back to its inactive form lyso-PAF, are both present(25). Acetylhydrolase activity has been demonstrated in human seminal plasma and a role for this enzyme as a decapacitation factor has been put forward(26). In preliminary experimentation in our laboratory we have noted a significant decrease in spermatozoal-acetylhydrolase activity upon capacitation, concurrent with an increase in endogenous PAF levels.
Following exposure of human and rabbit spermatozoa to synthetic PAF, flow cytometry revealed mobilization of Ca2+ in cells loaded with Indo-IAM(13). Progesterone and 17-hydroxypro-gesterone cause an immediate increase in free cytosolic sperm calcium(14). We have previously reported that a 15-minute exposure of rabbit spermatozoa to progesterone (1g/ml). produces both an increase in the synthesis and release of PAF(16). A similar mechanism seems to be operative in human spermatozoa(17, 27). The above studies suggest an intermediary role of PAF in the progesterone stimulation of sperm function and led us to propose that spermatozoa coming in contact with progesterone in female reproductive tract are stimulated to synthesize and secrete PAF. This secreted PAF, in an autocrine fashion, then stimulates sperm function via a cascade of secondary mediators(28).
Motility stimulation upon treatment of human spermatozoa has been documented utilizing both videomicrography and computer assisted motion analysis(29-31). Stimulation of penetration of cervical mucus and zona free hamster oocytes has also been reported upon treatment of human spermatozoa with synthetic PAF(32-34).
In animal studies, PAF treatment of murine and rabbit spermatozoa has been shown to significantly improve fertilization rates of oocytes in vitro utilization both conventional in vitro and microsurgical fertilization(35-40). Treatment of murine spermatozoa with PAF prior to insemination of oocytes had no detrimental effect on subsequent embryo development in vitro or in vivo. In addition, the reproductive efficiency of animals generated from embryos produced by PAF-treated sperm was not compromised as mating of these animals upon maturity resulted in the delivery of normal healthy pups(41).
PAF seems to be an intrinsic factor in spermatozoal function with roles in sperm transport, capacitation and fertilization of the oocyte. Embryonic PAF secretion and improved embryo viability with PAF treatment implicate PAF as a factor in development and implantation. Appropriately, studies are in progress to elucidate the complex functions of PAF in embryo development and implantation, as well as spermatozoal physiology and pharmacology.
Cytokines represent a spectrum of peptide hormones produced within the immune system and by other cell types in response to stimulation. Cytokines modulate spermatogenesis and sperm function. High concentrations of interferon-alpha and gamma (IFN) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF) have demonstrated deleterious effects on sperm motility and hamster penetration rates in the sperm penetration assay(42, 43). On the contrary, a recent report documented an increase in sperm count and motility in severely oligospermic patients receiving intramuscular injections of IFN-alpha(44).
Elegant work by Naz et al. (45) showed levels of Interleukin-6 (IL-6) to be significantly higher in the seminal plasma of infertile men when compared to fertile controls. Furthermore, in vitro incubation of sperm with IL-6 was shown by the same group to enhance motility parameters and penetration of zona free hamster oocytes(46). Thymosin alpha-1 has also been shown to enhance the capability of human sperm to penetrate zona free hamster oocytes and improved motility parameters. This effect was produced in spermatozoa from infertile males(47).
Pentoxifylline is a methylxanthine inhibitor of phosphodiestrase and improves motility of both fresh and cryopreserved human spermatozoa(48, 49). Cyclic adenosine 3', 5' - monophosphate (cAMP). is a known regulatory element of axonemal motility, and by its actions on protein phosphorylation may be responsible for pentoxifylline's actions. Elevated cAMP levels as a consequence of pentoxyifylline treatment may be modulating other events such as capacitation and acrosome reaction(50).
Prior to clinical application, animal studies assessed the embryo toxicity of pentoxifylline using murine IVF and embryo transfer (ET) models. No differences in the fertilization rates or subsequent rates of blastocyst formation were noted when pentoxifylline was washed out prior to insemination of murine oocytes. Pregnancy rates upon ET were also unaffected and offspring were normal(51).
The initial clinical application of pentoxifylline entailed exposure of the sperm to the adjuvant for a period greater than two hours prior to insemination of oocytes. In a small series of nine couples who had experienced up to three cycles of fertilization failure, five successful pregnancies were established with pentoxifylline-treated sperm(52). In subsequent studies, reducing sperm exposure to pentoxifylline to 30-40 minutes, gave significantly improved fertilization rates and fewer cases of fertilization failure. Significantly improved rates of fertilization and embryo yield continue to be observed in cases of severe oligoasthenozoospermia(53).
A 10-minute exposure of capacitated normozoospermic samples to pentoxyifylline (1 mg/ml) did not alter the percentage of motile cells but mean values of all other motion parameters were significantly different. Similar changes were also noted with asthenozoospermic samples. Significant increases in curvilinear velocity were noted for both types of specimens. Elevated curvilinear velocity was maintained in normozoospermic specimens one hour longer than asthenozoospermic specimens. Significant improvement in hyperactivation was also noted for both types of specimens(54). The improvements in motility for oligozoospermics are noted to be immediate and transient while for normozoospermics various motility parameters are sustained for periods ranging between one and four hours. Acrosome reaction ionophore challenge test (ARIC) measures the proportion of spermatozoa that respond to A23187 and demonstrates high sensitivity and predictive value for IVF(55). Pentoxifylline improves the fertilizing ability of spermatozoa in certain cases of acrosome reaction insufficiency. Prospective randomized studies have shown the ARIC test to be useful predictor of benefit for pentoxifylline treatment(56, 57).
Impaired sperm function has been associated with elevated levels of reactive oxygen species with a postulated mechanism being acrosomal membrane pertubation. The ensuing damage may cause the plasma membrane to lose its responsiveness to calcium influx signal that would otherwise trigger the acrosome reaction(58). Routine semen preparation may stimulate release of these damaging oxygen species from sperm cells. John Yovich and collegues at the PIVET Medical Center utilize the ARIC test in all cases of infertility as a diagnostic indicator of sperm function impairment. An ARIC score of less than 10% is repeated on a pentoxifylline-treated sample. Improved scores upon pentoxifylline treatment provides the basis for offering this adjuvant for intrauterine insemination (IUI), gamete intrafallopian transfer (GIFT) and IVF. Pregnancies have been generated from each of the above procedures utilizing pentoxifylline-treated sperm, resulting in the delivery of normal healthy infants. There is no increase in pregnancy wastage of fetal abnormalities when compared with matched controls undergoing assisted reproduction without pentoxifylline. More than 200 babies have been born from pentoxifylline-treated sperm without any increase in the incidence of congenital anomalies(57).
Treatment of male infertility has been revolutionized by the advent of intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). The procedure was perfected in the early 90's by Professor Van Steirteghem's group in Belgium. In a very short period the technology has been applied in assisted reproduction clinics world-wide.
Further advances have led to the development of round spermatid nuclei injection (ROSNI), a procedure that does not even require the completion of spermatogenesis in the male. Success has been achieved by the injection of round spermatid nuclei into oocytes(59). Spermatozoa extracted from the epididymis (MESA) and testis (TESA) also can serve as a source of male genetic complement in ICSI applications.
A desire of practitioners in the field has been to determine which patients would gain the most benefit from the application of ICSI. A retrospective review of data by the senior author provides new insight to this dilemma. Over a ten month period, January through October 1995, patients enrolled in the ICSI program were divided into three groups: Group I was male factor defined by the existance of abnormalities in one or more semen analysis parameters according to WHO standards and no female pathology evident. Group II was defined as the female factor and consisted of couples with normal semen parameters, but one or more conditions of: elevated day three FSH, poor response to gonadotropin stimulation, advanced maternal age (>39 years) or poor quality oocytes. Group III was defined as a combination of both male and female factors. On examining clinical pregnancy rates per transfer procedure, data clearly showed significant differences. Group I had a clinical pregnancy rate (30/75) of 40%. Group II had a clinical pregnancy rate of (5/46) 10.9%. The lowest pregnancy rate was seen in Group III at (5/97) 5.2%. Interestingly, fertilization and cleavage rates in the three categories were not signifcantly different(60). Several groups are beginning to review their data in a similar fashion in order to develop sound patient counseling strategies.